Black Lion Audio's MicroClock is an excellent dedicated master clock generator that will certainly improve the clarity of your A/D conversion.
>>> FULL REVIEW
With the GT 062, Glyph delivers an external hard drive with professional-grade components, a world-class warranty, & an innate understanding of their customers.
>>> FULL REVIEW
Sign up now for our Newsletter! We'll keep you updated on the lastest music news, releases, events and other important issues facing electronic music (plus we send you
free stuff if you include your mailing address!) >>> FutureMusic Direct
"The monitor's skyscraper size was a major problem in my studio...when placed on my Omnirax's monitor stands, the sweet spot was about 18 inches over my head"
--Greg Geller
"I thought they were difficult to work with, but I got my final mix to sound all right at the club, so there's something right going on..."
--Neville Carrol
"Although the separation of individual sounds was often impressive, the metallic quality of the upper mids would begin to grate on me after an hour or so of mixing."
--Garth Fields
"There was plenty of detail, even with the magnified bass, low-mid-range dip, and high-end hit."
--Lee Smith
"These speakers are for guys who listen with their eyes."
--Jim Stout
April 28, 2008
../ TestDrive: M-Audio EX66 Monitors
I'll let you in on a little secret, one of our favorite bits of kit to review are studio monitors. Why? Well, thanks to our collaborative review process,
some of our most heated, yet thoroughly entertaining, debates center around this vital studio component. Even though the evaluation of monitors is subjective
at best, the criteria for what makes a good pair of monitors is relatively simple. Does the mix you've created in your studio translate in the real world?
The design of the EX66's midwoofers are a collaboration with UCLA's Dept of Materials Science
M-Audio recently sent over their EX66 nearfield monitors for us to TestDrive. Although the
monitors have been around for about a year, the EX66's push M-Audio beyond their budget monitoring options and into a new price point for the concern. It's
obvious that M-Audio wanted to make a statement with the EX66's. Not only do they incorporate provocative new technology and features, but they also utilize
a dual woofer design that has lost favor with other manufacturers.
The one-inch, titanium-dome tweeter is located between the identical six inch, bass / mid-range
drivers and is housed behind a shaped waveguide to maintain the vertical and horizontal dispersion angles at the crossover frequency point. This layout is sometimes
referred to as a midwoofer-tweeter-midwoofer configuration, or MTM. The monitors are meant to be positioned vertically, not horizontally, with plenty of room needed behind
the speakers due to the rear bass exhaust port. This poses some problems in studios that have decks with monitor seats built-in, or non adjustable stands, since the
monitors are tall at 19 inches. M-Audio advises such positioning to narrow the sweet spot and to prevent the room's acoustics from significantly impeding the monitor's
capabilities.
Features:
MTM configuration
Two 6" custom linear-piston woofers
1" titanium dome tweeter
Bi-amplified with 200 watts PWM power per channel
DSP-tuned cabinets and crossovers
High-impedance analog inputs (XLR and TRS balanced)
S/PDIF and AES/EBU digital input up to 24-bit/192kHz
OptImage II high-frequency wave guide
Acoustic Space control
Soft limiter circuit to prevent clipping
Calibrated volume control/input sensitivity control
High-frequency roll-off/boost switch
Mid-range presence switch (low-Q dip or peak)
Low-cutoff switch (37Hz, 80Hz, 100Hz)
MDF cabinet
Internal adiabatic foam
Dual flange rear-port design
Magnetic shielding
Close-up of the M-Audio EX66's titanium tweeter
M-Audio enlisted the help of UCLA's Department of Materials Science for the design of the dual,
linear-piston midwoofers. M-Audio's engineers wanted a ultra-light cone that was resistant to frequencey breakup issues. Inverting the driver's dust cap, and
incorporating a Linkwitz-Riley crossover, give the EX66 a 2.56kHz crossover point with the intial breakup mode hitting at a claimed 6.5kHz. When the crossover
point does occurs, M-Audio designed the Linkwitz-Riley to reduce the signal level by 30dB, diminishing the potential for distortion to reduce the overall sound quality.
With the EX66, M-Audio has introduced their own proprietary driver technology that utilzes an
onboard digital signal processor instead of analog circuitry found in most monitors. This allows the concern to dial in the Infinite Impulse Response filters
to combat problematic cabinent resonances that they feel are detrimental. However, the signal is forced through an Analog to Digital To Analog conversion, which
proved problematic for many of the evaluators — more on this later.
Speaking of the cabinent, M-Audio went to great length to give the monitors a futuristic, yet
functional appearance. The front-edges of the smooth, black enclosures are curved for reduced diffraction, and two glowing blue LEDs let you know the monitors
are ready for action.
The EX66's are bi-amped with two individual 100-watt Pulse Width Modulation (PWM) power amps
to power the 4-ohm midwoofers and 4-ohm tweeter, which is certainy more than the tweeter requires, but who's complaining.
The EX66 has a full compliment of connectivity, volume and tone shaping controls
The back of the monitors contain plenty of I/O options including balanced XLR and TRS analog
inputs, a digital input (S/PDIF or AES-EBU), a volume knob, on/off switch and an Acoustic Space switch. The Acoustic Space can be set at either full (open space),
half (close to a wall) and quarter (close to a corner) Frequency control is available with +2dB, flat or -2dB High-frequency options, mid-range (flat or +2 dB)
boost, and three low-cut filter hits, 37, 80 or 100 Hz. These give you enough latitude to tackle any minor problems, and is a nice way to test consumer playback
devices that may be "bass-challenged."
Although, we're wary of the monitors' converters due to the EX66's price point, the S/PDIF receiver can lock to an incoming
clock of up to 216kHz, and the digital input can support a sample rate up 24-bit/192kHz, but is hard set at 24-bit/96kHz when the analog inputs are being utilized.
Intelligent connectivity selectors specify left channel, right channel or stereo for the digital input.
The Sound
So how do the EX66's sound? Every one of the evaluators noticed that the EX66's produced a
surprising amount of noise. We contacted two retailers about the issue who confirmed the problem with a simple "this isn't the first time we've heard that..."
and M-Audio acknowledged a certain level of audible hiss. The problem appears to stem from the internal DSP processing, as well as the A/D and D/A conversion.
Although, the issue never became a serious irritant when mixing, it definitely needs to be addressed by M-Audio.
The EX66's high-end "had a bit of a bite" according to most of the evaluators, which some classified as
"brassy" or "shrill." However, one tester found that the EX66's high-end prominence "helped the mixing process by forcing me not to over-hype the high-end."
The "hit" is most likely due to the inherent nature of the titanium in the tweeter, which put them "right up front."
The dual mid-range woofers provided plenty of bass, which most of the testers had to spend "some
time dialing in," but with the "plethora of bass management options" most testers were "pleased with the results." Once the bass was tuned, a couple
of the testers noted the "excellent definition and detail of individual tracks" even with a "mid-range scoop."
Stereo imaging was somewhat of a issue for a couple of testers and a major problem for
another. The narrow width, coupled with the height of the monitors are a question, since they are somewhat unwieldy for some studio environments. As stated
before, for users who have limited adjustable stands or mixing on a desk, the monitor's height will be a hornets' nest. In addition, the speakers configuration
narrows the stereo sweet spot, and moving your position will cause changes in the overal tonal quality. One tester attempted to rectify the problem by setting
the monitors on their side, in the horizontal position, but "immediately ran into phasing problems" in his nearfield location.
Our testers mixed a wide variety of electronic music genres using the EX66's with varied results.
On the plus side, even though the bass was somewhat "magnified" it did support an "extended spectrum" that ended up translating into a "defined low end."
The same can be said about the upper frequencies. Even though many of the evaluators found high-end to be "promenently pushed,"
it translated into the final mix "not having the harshness that sometimes silk-domed tweeters trick you into delivering" for one tester.
On the minus side, none of the evaulators found the EX66's pleasurable for extended periods of
mixing. "Although the separation of sounds is excellent for monitoring, the metallic quality of the upper mids would begin to grate on me after a while." The
majority of testers found that it took a substantial amount of time to "settle into the EX66's" to achieve favorable results. The
noise floor will obviously be a "nuisance for users who mix in very quiet environments." While one evaluator liked how the EX66's "kept my mixes honest" and
might consider them as a "second pair," nobody would choose them as their primarily monitoring solution, even at their attractive price point.
Conclusion
We like what M-Audio attempted to accomplish with the EX66 monitors. The technical progress
they achieved with the monitors in terms of the MTM configuration, the DSP processing, and the speaker design, all at a palatable price point for consumers,
will serve them well in the future if they continue to move forward with this series. Unfortunately, in this first incarnation, there's just too many negatives
for the EX66's to become a choice monitoring solution for fastidious ears.
The Future: First and foremost, if M-Audio decides to continue with this series, they needs to address
the DSP noise issue. A monitor, even in this price range, cannot have a built-in white noise generator. The onboard DSP is a provocative concept, but without serious
converters, it ends up being one step forward, two steps back. More mid-to-high range tuning may also help some users to eliminate some of the inbalance caused by the titanium
tweeter's inherent snap.
We respect M-Audio's aspirations for their EX66 monitors in terms of the MTM configuration, the DSP processing, and the midwoofer and tweeter design, however they made
too many compromises to reach their intended price point and the overall balance, neutrality and quality of the audio suffers.